PLAYOFFHOTELS

Dodgers at Yankees: The Call Slides to 50.4% as Storms Roll Toward the Bronx

Neither Saturday starter has a winning record, and the forecast calls for thunderstorms rolling into the Bronx by first pitch. The Call still likes LA, barely — 50.4%, down from Friday's 51%, with weather and a home pitching edge doing the moving.

Two sub-.500 starters, a soggy forecast, and a Yankee Stadium crowd that doesn’t need much of an excuse to get loud — Saturday’s Dodgers-Yankees game has less star power on the mound than Friday’s opener but arguably more chaos potential. Emmet Sheehan and Ryan Weathers are both a combined game under .500 this season, and the National Weather Service has thunderstorms penciled in for the Bronx by the time this one’s supposed to start.

What The Call sees

The Call gives Los Angeles 50.4% to win this one — still a lean toward the Dodgers, but a hair softer than the 51% the model had on this series a day earlier. Two things moved it: a modest home pitch factor favoring New York, and small wind and rain adjustments tied to the forecast. None of these are dramatic on their own — this remains fundamentally an Elo-driven number, with the Dodgers’ rating (1554) still comfortably ahead of the Yankees’ (1524) — but stacked together they were enough to erase a chunk of LA’s road edge without flipping the pick outright.

What could break the pick

The weather is the wild card worth watching first. The Bronx is looking at a 70% chance of showers and possible thunderstorms after 2pm, with gusts up to 25 mph by the evening window this game is scheduled in — the kind of forecast that raises real odds of a delay, a shortened bullpen night, or a game that simply plays differently than a dry one would. Rain tends to help pitchers who work off command and hurt ones who rely on breaking-ball spin, which cuts both ways here given how inconsistent both Sheehan and Weathers have been.

On the pitching matchup itself: Weathers’ 110 strikeouts against a 3-7 record suggests a pitcher who’s missing bats but not getting run support or bullpen help — a classic case where the surface stat undersells the arm. Sheehan’s 4.81 ERA is the shakier number of the two on paper, which is part of why the model’s small pitch factor leans toward New York rather than Los Angeles despite the Dodgers’ overall Elo advantage.

The trip

However the rain shakes out, a Dodgers-Yankees series at Yankee Stadium is a bucket-list draw either way — our Yankee Stadium guide covers how fans from both sides actually get in, where to stay, and what a Bronx crowd sounds like for a series this big.

FAQ

Who's pitching Saturday's game?

Emmet Sheehan for the Dodgers (4-6, 4.81 ERA, 93 strikeouts) against Ryan Weathers for the Yankees (3-7, 4.15 ERA, 110 strikeouts). Neither has a winning record, though Weathers' strikeout total is notably higher than his win-loss line suggests.

Is the game actually going to see rain?

The Bronx forecast for July 18 calls for showers and possible thunderstorms after 2pm with a 70% chance of precipitation, plus southwest winds around 10-15 mph gusting to 25 mph — enough that both wind and rain factors are built into The Call's number for this one.

Why did the Dodgers' number drop from Friday's game?

It's not a big move — 51% down to 50.4% — but a small pitch factor favoring the Yankees at home, plus modest wind and rain adjustments, both nudged the number a touch in New York's direction compared to the prior day's read.

More Matchup Mayhem

MLB · 2026-07-17 · THE CALL: 51% NYY
Los Angeles Dodgers at New York Yankees
MLB · 2026-07-17 · THE CALL: 52% CLE
Pittsburgh Pirates at Cleveland Guardians
MLB · 2026-07-17 · THE CALL: 51% TOR
Chicago White Sox at Toronto Blue Jays
MLB · 2026-07-17 · THE CALL: 61% ATL
Texas Rangers at Atlanta Braves
WNBA · 2026-07-17 · THE CALL: 57% ATL
Atlanta Dream at Toronto Tempo
WNBA · 2026-07-17 · THE CALL: 59% CHI
Los Angeles Sparks at Chicago Sky

Keep reading

EVENT PREVIEW
Orioles at Astros: A Pitching Factor Finally Showed Up — And It Points at Baltimore
EVENT PREVIEW
White Sox at Blue Jays: The Pick Just Flipped, and the Mound Tells You Why
EVENT PREVIEW
Reds at Rockies: Same 51.2% As Yesterday — Because Both Rotations Are Still a Mess